Ask a Question - or - Return to the Spiritual Warfare Forum Index

Question Title Posted By Question Date
Homeopathy and diagnostic tools Bernice Friday, September 25, 2009

Question:

Hi Bro Ignatius and Team,

Whilst feeling rather ill I was taken to an iridologist yesterday by a the best Catholic I know; a friend who has visited him for years. The naturopath is a friendly elderly gentleman but did have pictures in his office of buddha and the dalai lama as well as rosaries and other Catholic pictures. He started with asking my birthdate and examining my hands and eyes then proceeded to give a spot on analysis of my current emotional and physical state. It contained what I already knew in both areas.

I also asked him about my son (who was not present) and he told me he could help him, and asked his birthdate too.

I asked him whether he got his diagnostic information because of 'star signs' and he told me that Nicholas Culpeper (the herbalist) taught that astronomy and plants were linked. You must use plants that correspond with the season in which the person was born. I pointed out some inconsistencies I know about astrology (c/- Fr Pacwa's book) and he agreed that horoscopes (that is, star signs which predict current events) are total rubbish. But, he maintained that the astronomy+plants element is true, and should be applied with the features of someone's temperament (given sign they were born later).

He then gave me homeopathic remedies which will last a month and told me he could fix me up very well.

Whilst he pointed out exactly what was happening physically and how I can return to normal, I feel uncomfortable that he used star signs as part of his diagnostic tool. I have no problem with iridology as a diagnostic tool (please tell me however if I should!!) but I don't like any link with tools that originate from other religions or especially astrology/astronomy.

Have I sinned by going to this fellow and sin further if I continue to take the homeopathic remedies? I intend to see my confessor in the next few days and will follow whatever his advice is also.

If you could shed some light on this I would appreciate it.

Thankyou,

Bernice



Question Answered by Bro. Ignatius Mary, OLSM

Dear Bernice:

From your description of this man's practice, I think it is clear that you should not go to him. He is using methods that are incompatible with Christianity and is decidedly is into the New Age lunacy.

Iridology, by the way, is quackery. There is no scientific basis for its claims.

As for homeopathy, it is best to stay with established methods that have a proven track record. "However," as stated by Dr. Rosenfeld in his book Dr. Rosenfeld's Guide to Alternative Medicine, "for symptoms that are not life-threatening, and for which conventional medicine has either no treatment or a potentially toxic treatment, homeopathy may be a reasonable alternative."

Dr. Rosenfeld continues, "If you decide to go that route, consult a reputable practitioner who is also an M.D."

While homeopathic medicine in itself is not a problem when properly administered by a qualified practitioner who is also an M.D., there are some cautions that must be considered:

1) As with any medical remedy or procedure, there is no such thing as a cure-all, a magic bullet, a substance that can cure everything. Some people in the homeopathic movement make claims about various herbs and substances that are scientifically unverifiable and are exaggerated to the four winds. Stay away from such things. Herbs, as with any substance, are effective for a limited number of issues; avoid exaggerated claims. Find out what has been proven to work for a specific condition or issue and limit oneself to those remedies.

2) While there has been much improvement over the last decade, there is still a problem with the quality-control of herbs and substances in homeopathy. One is never sure of the quality, potency, and dose of herbs on the market; there are no regulatory standards which with herbal companies must follow. If buying these products, be sure to do your research to find a company that offers the best quality-control, precise potency and dosage.

3) Herbs are not safe merely because they are "natural". There are contraindications and adverse reactions that can exist between herbs and between the herbs and other "regular" medications. It is possible to do great damage to oneself by homeopathic self-medication when one does not know about overdose limits, contraindications, adverse reactions, and other factors. It is possible to even die from such contraindications and adverse reactions.

It is critically important, therefore, that one know the potency of a herb, what dosage is safe, and what contraindications and adverse reactions that may exist.

The people who publish the PDR (Physicians Desk Reference) now have a PDR the deals specifically with herbs called the PDR for Herbal Medicines. Anyone practicing homeopathy NEEDS to buy this volume and learn how to use it. It is expensive, around $60, but it is a necessity.

Here is brochure description of the PDR for Herbal Medicines

Building on its best-selling predecessors, the new PDR for Herbal Medicines, Third Edition has left no resource unturned to bring together the latest scientific data in the most comprehensive herbal reference compiled.

The third edition goes far beyond the original source, adding a new section on Nutritional Supplements and new information aimed at greatly enhancing patient management by medical practitioners. All monographs have been updated to include recent scientific findings on efficacy, safety and potential interactions; clinical trials (including abstracts); case reports; and meta-analysis results. This new information has resulted in greatly expanded Effects, Contraindications, Precautions and Adverse Reactions, and Dosage sections of each monograph.

  • Indexed by common name
  • Asian, Indian and Homeopathic Herbs Index
  • Safety Guide
  • Daily dosage information for unprocessed herbs and commercially available brand name products
  • Manufacturers' Index, including name, address, contact information and product list
  • Trade names of available products added to each monograph
  • Expanded Drug/Herb Interaction Guide
  • Therapeutic Category Index
  • Clinical Management of Interactions

To buy this volume, Click Here.

4) When consulting a homeopathic practitioner be VERY careful. Homeopathy is a major interest in the New Age. A LOT of practitioners may also be involved in the New Age, occult, or even witchcraft activities. Avoid such people.

Following these guidelines, one should be able to navigate homeopathy world successfully.

Anyone with an interest in Alternative Medicine needs to read up on what really works and doesn't work. "Testimonials" from the company selling the product, or from your next door neighbor are utterly useless. One needs to have a scientific approach to analyze the claims of various Alternative Medicine claims. 

I recommend the book by Isadore Rosenfeld, M.D., Dr. Rosenfeld's Guide to Alternative Medicine : What Works, What Doesn't And What's Right for You

Dr. Rosenfeld is open to Alternative methods, and gives a fair and balanced evaluation of more than thirty alternative therapies. He gives the history of each therapy, explains a little about how the therapy is suppose to work, gives scientific information and research on the topic, and ends with a no nonsense "bottomline".  Dr. Rosenfeld begins his book with excellent chapters on people searching for hope are lured by alternative methods with clear advice on how to proceed with hopeful alternatives, the nature of the placebo effect, and how to spot a quack.

I highly recommend this book.

God Bless,
Bro. Ignatius Mary


For information on how to receive help see our Help page. We suggest that before contacting us directly for help you try the Seven Steps to Self-Deliverance. These self-help steps will often resolve the problem. Also our Spiritual Warfare Prayer Catalog contains many prayers that may be helpful. If needed you can ask for a Personal Consultation.