Ask a Question - or - Return to the Faith and Spirituality Forum Index

Question Title Posted By Question Date
Another Confession/Mortal Sin Question Cody Saturday, August 31, 2013

Question:

Sorry to ask another one of these questions. I've tried to avoid it, but right now it will help me remain obedient to my confessor. I only feel comfortable asking him these questions inside the confessional. Since to remain obedient I must wait a couple of weeks this won't be an option. As a result, I could end up abstaining from the Eucharist, needlessly.

So first, in confession I was mentioning a sin the needed background information. It helped me mention how I fell into sin multiple times from the same thing. The sins were too different for me to lump together. Also, this information helped me to move into mentioning the actual sins (it truly wasn't unnecessary information). Well during this time I realized I had forgotten something ( two sins). I briefly tried to recall it, but couldn't. If I had thought longer I would have, but I was embarrassed to make the priest wait too long. So I figured I had tried my best and moved on. Also, there was a point where I had to confess something I feared the priest would be offended by. When I finally got the courage to say it, my voice clearly showed disgust. I'm unsure if this was done to make it seem like I was more disgusted than I was (so he would be less mad) or because I was embarrassed to mention it. I did state that my actions were wrong and that I didn't approve so that he would be less angered (I did it with some other sins that I was nervous to confess). Lastly, when I did pause for a while I mentioned that I wanted to be careful so that I didn't worry afterwards. I mentioned my long period of abstaining from the Eucharist so that he would be more willing to wait. I decided that my confession was valid and I received the Eucharist. Was this the right decision?

During Mass I began thinking about something I confessed. It involved me drifting towards an unorthodox view in regards to the need for ad orientem. I was thinking about how it was equal to versus populum. This caused me to look at the priest to see what his orientation was. I guess this wasn't sinful, but at the time it bothered me. I began to reassert that both were equal and allowed by the Church. This lead me to think that there was more symbolism in ad orientem. I reminded my self that there was symbolism in versus populum, I just didn't know about it and also, people do prefer that method. I began to think, what if I can't find the symbollism. I pictured my self rejecting versus populum if that was the case (which would have been stupid). Soon after, I came up with the idea that versus populum better symbolised the last supper. This caused me to think that if this where the goal than why don't we all just sit in a circle during Mass (I pictured on the floor because of a women priest "mass " I saw). I reminded myself that that comparison was wrong. I couldn't compare a legitimate posture, at the alter, to sitting on the floor. So did I commit a mortal sin? This sounds scrupulous to me, but I'll leave it to be sure.

Thanks



Question Answered by Bro. Ignatius Mary, OMSM(r), CCL, LTh, DD, LNDC

Dear Cody:

If you have doubts about your disposition to receive the Eucharist, then abstain from the Eucharist. That is okay. The Church only requires reception once a year. It is far better to abstain than to receive when not properly disposed.

Cody, there is no such thing as "needed background information." In fact, explaining the circumstances of sin can sometimes be a sin in itself, the sin of pride. The circumstances are irrelevant as there is no excuse for sin no matter what the circumstance.

Unless the priest asks for details, just list your sins by kind and number. That is all the Church requires. If you genuinely forget a sin, that sin is forgiven anyway when the the priest absolves you. If you remember it later, then mention is in a future confession. A traditional statement at the end of confessing the sins on your list is, "For these and all other sins that I do not now remember I am heartedly sorry..."

The in no such thing as the priest being "offended" at the confession of some sin. This fear comes from the devil trying to get you to not confess the sin. Ignore that fear and confess whatever needs to be confessed.

Even if one has committed every sin that exists, one's confession will last only 10 minutes at most, unless the priest has questions, since all we are required to do is to mention the kind of sin and the number of times committed. The confessional is not a time for psychological counseling. It is a time to confess your sins, so confess them without the backstory.

You confession is valid as long has you confess all your sins that you remember at the time, and have proper contrition. A confession is not valid when you purposely refuse to confess some grave sin, or if you have no contrition. Thus, never allow fear or embarrassment to keep you from confessing some sin.

Your imaginings that you speak of are not sinful. You seem to have worked out the solutions and came to proper conclusions.

If you have thoughts that are intrusive, then rebuke those thoughts. We have a prayer called Controlling Thoughts and also one on Rebuking Particular Spirits (when thoughts may be inspired by demons). These are found in our Spiritual Warfare Prayer Catalog.

I think that you are tending to scrupulosity (which is the religious form of obsessive compulsive tendencies). I would suggest finding a good spiritual director to help you sort out these things.

God Bless,
Bro. Ignatius Mary

 


Footer Notes: This forum is for general questions on the faith. See specific Topic Forums below:
Spiritual Warfare, demons, the occult go to our Spiritul Warfare Q&S Forum.
Liturgy Questions go to our Liturgy and Liturgical Law Q&A Forum
Liturgy of the Hours (Divine Office) Questions go to our Divine Office Q&A Forum
Defenfing the Faith Questions go to our Defending the Faith Q&A Forum
Church History Questions go to our Church History Q&A Forum