Ask a Question - or - Return to the Faith and Spirituality Forum Index

Question Title Posted By Question Date
Should I attend wedding? Chas Sunday, September 23, 2012

Question:

Back on 3-9-09 I asked you about this young friend of mine (at my age anybody in their 50's is a young person) who was attending non-catholic services besides attending Mass. One of the last times I met with him we had a long discussion concerning Church teachings and I point blank asked him if he was still attending Mass and if he considered himself still a Catholic. His reply was,"Well, I guess I'm not Catholic anymore." I had warned him previously about the danger he was placing his soul if he decided to leave the Catholic Church.

He grew up knowing quite a bit since he attended a very Orthodox parish, but due to his involvement with non-catholic friends he started believing their teachings. I had mentioned to him before that any objection that has ever been brought up against Catholic teachings have been debunked over and over again. He was now against Marian teachings and devotions and stated that the Bible had only one thing to say about the queen of heaven and it was bad. I told him that I was going to have to have a long, long talk with him regarding that passage. I didn't get a chance to explain as he had dropped me off at home after lunch and he was in a rush to get back to work.

I hadn't heard from him but my son would hear from him on occasions through Facebook. I found out he met another girl a few months ago while doing missionary work for some non-denominational church in Central America and now they are getting married.

I am saddened by his decision to leave the CC as I have known him since he was nine and he is 27 now. I know that I should not attending a wedding of a Catholic in a non-catholic ceremony but since he stated that he is no longer Catholic does that make a difference?

It's going to be at a garden restaurant. He just met this girl a couple of months ago and just less then a months ago they announced their engagement and the wedding will be in two months. Personally I can't in all honesty tell him I'm happy for him and all I think I could say is that I'm praying for him. 


You comments please and thank you.



Question Answered by

Dear Chas:

The answer would be easy if this fella still thought of himself as Catholic. The answer would be certainly no if he was still Catholic marrying outside the Catholic Church. 

A Protestant baptized man and a Protestant baptized woman who marry have a valid and sacramental marriage. But, if a Catholic marries outside the Church without the bishop's dispensation, then the marriage is not valid, even if the wife is baptized.

In this case we have a Catholic man who has defected from the true Faith in favor of some non-denominational denomination (an ecclesial community, since this non-denomination and all Protestant groups are not valid "Churches" properly so-called).

More disturbing is that this defected Catholic, now Protestant, is intending a marriage ceremony in a restaurant and not in a "church" building? I am utterly amazed how disrespectfully people treat the holy estate of marriage by getting married in a balloon, underwater, on the beach, while sky-diving, before a justice-of-the-peace, and many other myriad ways, and now in a place of eats (how profane can people be).

Frankly, I would not attend the wedding just because this fella and his intended one have no class and prefer to sully the sanctity of marriage by having the ceremony in a restaurant of all places. How crude and profane.

It is possible to attend a wedding of a defected Catholic if that defection is complete, the person has no intention of going to Mass and receiving the Eucharist ever again, and when there is no reasonable expectation that this foolish soul will ever re-vert and come home.

This, however, is presuming the defected Catholic, now Protestant, is having a "church" wedding in their denominational "church" building.

I would even say that it may be possible to attend even if the wedding is in some neutral location, like a beach, lakeside, or even in a meeting hall at some hotel, but in a restaurant? A place where people are masticating? Does this couple think a marriage ceremony is just a party? Walk down the aisle while eating a chicken leg? For pete sake.

It is up to your conscience. You need to follow your conscience.

But, in my opinion, even if everything else is okay, I would not attend because of how this couple intends to be married. Their intentions for the ceremony show, I believe, that they are not ready for marriage. They are too immature and have no idea what marriage is about. If I were in this situation I would not attend the marriage because of the mockery they are making of the ceremony and because of the gross immaturity of this couple. But, that is me.

God Bless,
Bro. Ignatius Mary


Footer Notes: This forum is for general questions on the faith. See specific Topic Forums below:
Spiritual Warfare, demons, the occult go to our Spiritul Warfare Q&S Forum.
Liturgy Questions go to our Liturgy and Liturgical Law Q&A Forum
Liturgy of the Hours (Divine Office) Questions go to our Divine Office Q&A Forum
Defenfing the Faith Questions go to our Defending the Faith Q&A Forum
Church History Questions go to our Church History Q&A Forum