Ask a Question - or - Return to the Faith and Spirituality Forum Index

Question Title Posted By Question Date
Failing to Confess ones Sins Christina Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Question:

Brother Ignatius Mary,

Please forgive me, I don't think on some of the points that I mentioned that I expressed myself as I intended. - I have a difficult time expressing myself verbally let alone in writing.

I did not intend for you to get the impression that I find it so "fantastical" to learn that a Nun committed a Mortal sin. That is far from what I feel! In fact, I find it extremely frightening! What I meant is that I fine it hard to believe that a mortal sin could be left out of Confession. Especially, a sin of impurity if one only needs to state the number of times and say 'sin of impurity'. But, as you stated I am wrong in my understanding on how to confess.

Do you have a list of the sins of impurity? Does the Church have a list of the sins of impurity?

I did not leave my index cards at home. I brought them with me. At first, I thought I should have read them out loud but then it got close to the 1 hour mark and I just mentioned a few. (What I thought were the Mortal sins and important ones). I said something to the Priest that it is not necessary to read them all, as I wrote them down and the Priest agreed. So, I figured that was ok. - That if I should have read them all - which I would have, the Priest would have told me. - God knows what is in my heart. I did the best that I could at that time. However, I left out a lot of the sins against God - and those are Mortal sins.

I did go to confession afterwards, and explained to the Priest all of this. I went maybe 5 additional times to discuss all of this. During one time, I told the Priest about the sins I left out (during the evil presence) - I said them each (what I could remember) verbally. During another Confession, I attempted to tell the priest about my sins of impurity and he said I did not need to say them - that I genuinely forgot about them during my confession - they are not Mortal sins. - Acts of impurity that I participated in. Another time, I told the Priest that I am plagued with worry that I did not confess properly. He wanted to know if I held anything back. I told him I don't think so. So, he said to move forward. Another time I told the Priest the same thing - I am plagued that I did not confess properly. He said he would pray for me and that I did not need to do over a General Confession - I think 4 separate Priests said this to me.

So, my plan was to just move forward. And, I did just that! - But, then I saw what Jack wrote and it sounded so familiar to me that I just had to comment. Instead, I will schedule to see my Priest - another one in the Church and do over my General Confession. I certainly will write everything down that I could remember, and say in words everything. My concern is the sins against God that I did not say verbally, those are Mortal sins. I also stole things - those are Mortal sins and I did not say those verbally. And, also everything that I did not say that was on the index cards.

I will not receive Communion until I do over my General Confession. But, Brother Ignatius Mary, I think I did the best that I could. I did not intentionally hold back anything and I mentioned about saying the sins verbally. But, the Priest did not seem to think that I had to do that.

Unfortunately, I sense that my Priests are very liberal. I will pray for them. That is all I can do.

Do you remember the Nun? I would like to know if what occurred was actually valid? One Priest stated that he did not think this was true? So, I am now questioning this.

Thank you for your site. I am learning so much. Unfortunately I think I am doing it the hard way! But, I am learning.



Question Answered by

Dear Christina:

I think you are missing my point. I call it fantastical to have a lack of belief that a mortal sin could be left out of the Nun's confession. There is nothing surprising in that. Nun's are human and this Nun apparently was so consumed with pride that she refused to confess an embarrassing mortal sin. By the way, you keep referring to this Nun's sin as "impurity." We do not know what her sin was. You need to stop referring to her sin as that of impurity.

In any event, that was a story to illustrate a point about deliberately refusing to confess a sin. That is all it was, for pete sake. Let it go.

You say:

What I meant is that I fine it hard to believe that a mortal sin could be left out of Confession. Especially, a sin of impurity if one only needs to state the number of times and say 'sin of impurity'. But, as you stated I am wrong in my understanding on how to confess.

I answered this thoroughly. Did you not read my answer? I'll answer it again, I guess. People leave out mortal sins from their confessions all the time. It is embarrassment born of pride that causes them to do that. It is that simple. Do not try to make it more than it is. People do all sorts of crazy and nonsensical things under the influence of pride. That is why Pride is listed first among the seven deadly sins.

As to confessing impurity, you need to say MORE than "I committed the sin of impurity," as I extensively explained in the previous post. "Impurity" comes in many kinds. You need to confess what kind of impurity it is. To fail to confess the kind of impurity is again based on embarrassment born of pride. Just confess the sins. Stop all this hair-splitting.

And again, there is no such thing as having to take more than one hour to confess one's sins unless you are telling the stories behind the sins. STOP IT. Just give the list and then if the priest wants to hear more he will ask.

You cannot just mention "a few" of your sins. You must list ALL of your sins in kind and number (explanations not needed) for a confession to be a good one. Even if you committed every sin mentioned in the Bible and by the Church,every sin there is,  it would not take a hour. Stop spending time with the explanations and stories. 

The only reason spend that much time in confessional is pride and not taking responsibility for your own actions. IT DOES NOT MATTER what the story is, what the circumstances are. Just list the sins in kind and number as I have already explained and exampled in previous posts.

If you need pastoral counseling, make an appointment with the priest to meet weekly (or however often needed) outside of the Confessional. The Confessional is not the place for therapy, it is to confess sins, and perhaps receive a brief counsel and encouragement from the priest.

You need to take that same advice I gave to Jack about the nature of confession.

A list of impurities? Impurity is:

  • any sex act outside of marriage between one man and one woman.
  • any sex act within marriage that degrades the human person, such as S&M, bondage, domination, and other things too disgusting to mention, and such.
  • indulging in lustful thoughts toward others not your spouse.
  • indulging in lascivious behavior (behavior that inspires sexual desire or lustful thoughts in someone other than one's spouse.
  • Immodest behavior or dress

On modesty, St. John Chrysostom written more than 1600 years ago:

You carry your snare everywhere and spread your nets in all places. You allege that you never invited others to sin. You did not, indeed, by your words, but you have done so by your dress and your deportment and much more effectively than you could by your voice.

When you have made another sin in his heart, how can you be innocent?

Tell me, whom does this world condemn? Whom do judges in court punish? Those who drink poison or those who prepare it and administer the fatal potion? You have prepared the abominable cup, you have given the death-dealing drink, and you are more criminal than are those who poison the body; you murder not the body but the soul. And it is not to enemies you do this, nor are you urged on by any imaginary necessity, nor provoked by injury, but out of foolish vanity and pride.

We need to be modest in our dress, our deportment, in our language, and in our behavior. We need to practice the virtue of Temperance and not allow our emotions and passion to rule over us. But, when we do fail, the Sacrament of Confession is there to cleanse us

Since you appear to be suffering possibly from Scrupulosity, which is the religious form of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCD), I suggest that you consult with a psychiatrist to determine if you do have OCD or some other disorder. Medication is available that can help you to think more clearly by reducing your OCD tendency.

Also, my suggestion, in order to not feed into the OCD, is to move on. It sounds like you have been told this repeatedly. Do not go for another General Confession. If you have done one before there is no need to do another one. Hanging on to past sins, worrying about past sins and past confessions is a form of pride and/or a psychiatric condition, or both.

Move on with your life and stop obsessing about the past confessions. In your next confession confess only those sins you have committed since your last confession. The priest has told you to move on, so you have an obligation to obey and move on.

God Bless,
Bro. Ignatius Mary

 


Footer Notes: This forum is for general questions on the faith. See specific Topic Forums below:
Spiritual Warfare, demons, the occult go to our Spiritul Warfare Q&S Forum.
Liturgy Questions go to our Liturgy and Liturgical Law Q&A Forum
Liturgy of the Hours (Divine Office) Questions go to our Divine Office Q&A Forum
Defenfing the Faith Questions go to our Defending the Faith Q&A Forum
Church History Questions go to our Church History Q&A Forum