Ask a Question - or - Return to the Faith and Spirituality Forum Index

Question Title Posted By Question Date
Confession Lisa Saturday, March 24, 2012

Question:

My question is whether my confession was a good one. Here are the facts. I barely got a whole two sentences out to explain my sin and the confessor got impatient with me for how i stated my sin. Truth be told i always draw a blank right before confession, and that is my fault i know, but i never over-stay my confession and am concise. Being concise is partly helped by the fact I make a really good examination of conscience beforehand, so drawing a blank before confession is such a weird thing, and a suffering to me as well as the priest. When he got impatient with me, I got even MORE confused, and began to cry, and told him that I was so embarrassed. I took a minute more to finish the confession as I cried. I DID NOT hear his penance that he gave me since i was so dizzy and upset. (capitalization for emphasis, not yelling--sorry) I think he said pray three Hail Mary's, but I don't even remember because i ran out crying.

I prayed whatever I could in the Meditation Garden in the front of the church, because I didn't want to disturb others in the church. prayed way more than three Hail Mary's---incase he mentioned more, but don't we have to pray the set amount of prayers, or the confession was not good?

Truth be told even if you think I am being a baby about my life, I am very very upset about some other stuff which made me very sensitive. I won't mention them anymore, because you taught me to be quiet about them ( you did---it was very implicit, but i figured it out, ;-) thank you and God Bless You ), and I am not really good about suffering alone with God. I DID NOT TELL him my "woes" because I KNOW that is not what confession is for. I don't want it to matter to me whether he was justified or not in being impatient with me, but it sure did make me feel so much more that God doesn't favor me. I had a hundred temptations afterwards. And i know that that shouldn't even matter to me, but i am just this big wad of imperfection and sin. God help me.


I also don't KNOW how I can get OVER drawing a blank before confession. I make a good examination, and try to stick to a few sentences that explain the sin, and i stay with only two venial sins after I have confessed serious sin. But now I am so CONFUSED, because I HAVE tried to help this problem. I am afraid to go back to confession now and fear my last confession was not good.



Question Answered by

Dear Lisa:
I am sorry to hear about your experience in confession. The priest should never be impatient, but priests are human, too. Forgive him.

As to your questions, a good confession is when:

1) you confess all grave sins since your last confession and do not hold any back, 
2) you are contrite, sorry for your sins
3) you resolve to repent of your sins, that is, have a firm purpose of amendment
4) promise to try to avoid the near occasion of sin

When the priest absolves you, you are forgiven, and are to perform whatever penance assigned to you.

Since you do not remember what the penance was for sure, your saying many Hail Marys shows the desire of your heart that you are not trying to avoid the penance. In my opinion, it is a good confession.

One thing you may need to remember, is that we are not required to "explain" our sins. In fact, explanations can be in some people a way to try to justify their sins.

The Church requires that we confess only kind and number, unless the priests asks us for details.

Thus, as an example, let us say that I shoplifted at Pennys, Sears, and Target; that I was uncharitable to a co-worker, to my uncle, and to the next door neighbor, and that I had lustful thoughts about my boss, the next door neighbor, and some girl on the street.

My confession would be as follows:

Bless me Father, for I have sinned. It has been one week since my last confession. In that time I accuse myself of shoplifting three times, that I was uncharitable to three people, and I had lustful imaginations three times. For these and all my other sins which I cannot now remember, I am heartily sorry and firmly resolve never to sin again, and ask of you, Father, pardon, penance, and counsel?. 

The details are not needed at all unless the priest asks for them.

As for going blank before confession, write down the sins in advance while you are home when you do an Examination of Conscience. Then take the list with you when you go to the confessional. Be sure to destroy the list afterwards so no one will read it. Either burn it or tear it into little pieces.

There is no need for fear. When you go to confession next time, you can tell the priest iif you wish that you forgot the penance at your last confession, but that you said whatever number of Hail Marys for your penance. He will surely tell you that you did good. Then go on with your Confession as usual.

If you keep your confession to the simple "Kind and Number" as the Church advises, perhaps the priest will not get impatient.

If you do not know the number of times you committed the sin, then say, "I committed ___ numerous times, not sure of the number. If the priest insists on a number, then make an educated guess.

Be not afraid! Your last Confession sounds like a good one. You just forgot the penance. I have had that happen too. God knows your heart.


God Bless,
Bro. Ignatius Mary

 


Footer Notes: This forum is for general questions on the faith. See specific Topic Forums below:
Spiritual Warfare, demons, the occult go to our Spiritul Warfare Q&S Forum.
Liturgy Questions go to our Liturgy and Liturgical Law Q&A Forum
Liturgy of the Hours (Divine Office) Questions go to our Divine Office Q&A Forum
Defenfing the Faith Questions go to our Defending the Faith Q&A Forum
Church History Questions go to our Church History Q&A Forum